U.S. Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee sharply condemned an attack on a West Bank church during a visit to the region, calling the act a "crime" and demanding firm legal consequences.

According to the Western Journal, the ambassador’s strong remarks highlighted emerging rifts between U.S. leadership and the Israeli government in the wake of rising violence and political friction.

Huckabee, a longtime supporter of Israel and former pastor, made the comments during a Saturday appearance in Taybeh, a Palestinian village in the occupied West Bank. The visit came shortly after Israeli settlers allegedly attacked a Christian church in the area, prompting concern from international and religious communities. Huckabee, representing the administration of President Donald Trump, was visibly frustrated by the incident and its implications.

While the Trump administration has maintained steadfast support for Israel, it has drawn boundaries regarding engagement in the region. The administration has stated that it will not overlook the most aggressive actions by the Israeli government without evaluating the broader consequences. Huckabee’s statements mark one of the most direct criticisms from a top U.S. official during Trump's presidency regarding domestic Israeli conduct.

The ambassador labeled the church incident as a terrorist act. “It is an act of terror,” Huckabee declared from the site. “And it’s a crime. It should be consequenced and it should be consequenced harshly, because it is one the last bastions of our civilization — the places we worship.”

Netanyahu Responds to West Bank and Gaza Incidents

In response to the violence, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu issued a rare statement acknowledging that stray ammunition had hit Gaza’s Holy Family Church, an incident not directly linked to the Taybeh attack but which deepened religious tensions. “Israel deeply regrets that a stray ammunition hit Gaza’s Holy Family Church. Every innocent life lost is a tragedy. We share the grief of the families and the faithful,” read a statement from Netanyahu’s office.

The prime minister’s office also confirmed that Israeli authorities are investigating the situation. “Israel is investigating the incident and remains committed to protecting civilians and holy sites,” the statement added. The acknowledgment marked a significant public stance amid ongoing scrutiny.

Ambassador Huckabee emphasized the urgency of pursuing those responsible for the Taybeh attack. “Those who carry out acts of terror and violence in Taybeh — or anywhere — (should) be found and be prosecuted. Not just reprimanded; that’s not enough,” he stated, insisting that leniency would not restore trust among affected religious communities.

Church Attack Strains Relations With Faith-Based Groups

Huckabee has long advocated for Christian tourism and pilgrimage to the Holy Land. As a former pastor, he has built relationships with numerous faith-based groups that regularly travel to Israel. However, during his visit, he criticized Israeli immigration policies that have restricted access to the region for several Christian organizations.

Speaking candidly, Huckabee accused the Israeli government of sending the wrong message. “We feel we are being treated as adversaries,” he said, referencing recently imposed travel restrictions that have made it more difficult for some Christian ministries to enter the country. His remarks followed complaints from evangelical and Catholic groups about increasing limitations on their activities and movement.

Huckabee noted that such policies could undermine Israel’s long-term alliances with communities that have historically offered strong, vocal support. His warning reflects growing frustration among Western Christian leaders who view pilgrimage access as essential to their faith and international religious diplomacy.

Ambassador Shows Frustration Over Gaza Stalemate

Aside from the West Bank violence, Huckabee also addressed the broader conflict in the region, particularly in Gaza. Wearing a yellow ribbon on his lapel — a symbol of solidarity for Israeli hostages held since October 2023 — he said he remained hopeful for an imminent cease-fire. “I hope so. I hope so,” Huckabee replied when asked about the prospects for peace.

At the same time, Huckabee appeared emotionally burdened by the lack of progress. Suggesting his patience was running out, he remarked, “I’m going to take this off — forever,” referring to the yellow ribbon if a ceasefire deal fails to materialize. The gesture underscored his growing concern about the prolonged cycle of violence and the fate of civilians on both sides.

The comment drew attention in both Israeli and American media, seen by some as a symbolic warning that support could erode if concrete steps toward peace are not taken. Such statements from a Trump ally carry particular weight given their potential influence over evangelical political supporters back in the United States.

Calls for Accountability Amid Broader Diplomatic Pressure

Huckabee’s sharp rhetoric is notable given his consistent backing of Israel over the years, including headline-making visits and speeches in Jerusalem in support of Israeli sovereignty. Saturday’s remarks, however, signaled a shift toward a more conditional form of support tied to human rights and religious freedom concerns.

Some administration officials have suggested that while unwavering support for Israel remains U.S. policy, there is growing pressure behind the scenes to address settler violence and ensure greater protections for religious minorities. Huckabee’s comments add voice to this emerging chorus within Trump’s foreign policy team.

As investigations continue into both the West Bank church attack and the damage to Gaza’s Holy Family Church, international observers are watching closely to see whether Israel will follow through with meaningful action against those involved. Meanwhile, Huckabee concluded his visit by reiterating the need for accountability and calling for peaceful coexistence among faith groups.