Actor from 'How I Met Your Mother' sentenced to over three decades in prison for stabbing ex-girlfriend
A jury's guilty verdict last month has now landed 36-year-old actor Nick Pasqual behind bars for more than thirty years. Pasqual, who appeared on CBS's How I Met Your Mother, was sentenced Tuesday for stabbing his ex-girlfriend, makeup artist Allie Shehorn, more than 20 times at her Los Angeles home in May 2024.
The sentence caps a case that began with a restraining order filed just days before the attack, and ended with Pasqual's arrest at the United States, Mexico border after he fled California.
Breitbart News reported that a jury found Pasqual guilty last month of attempted murder and forcible rape. He was also convicted of first-degree residential burglary and multiple counts of injuring a spouse, cohabitant, or partner, Fox 5 Atlanta reported.
A restraining order filed days before the attack
The timeline makes the violence all the more difficult to absorb. Shehorn had filed for a restraining order against Pasqual just days before the stabbing, accusing him of domestic violence, People reported. Whatever legal protection that order was supposed to provide, it did not stop what happened next.
Prosecutors said Pasqual broke into Shehorn's home in May 2024 and inflicted "great bodily injury upon the victim under circumstances involving domestic violence."
Shehorn described the moment in her own words during testimony. She took the stand last month bearing visible scars on her arm and neck, ABC7 reported.
"I locked the door and he just started punching holes in that door and broke that open, and I just ran into the bathroom because I thought there's another lock on that door."
That locked bathroom door was not enough. Shehorn sustained stab wounds to her throat, back, chest, and wrists. She underwent 14 hours of surgery and spent several days in the intensive care unit.
Her friend Christine White found her after the attack. In 2024, White told the Los Angeles Times what she said to Shehorn in those critical moments.
"I just told her to keep her hand on her throat to stop the bleeding."
That a friend had to deliver emergency medical instructions to a woman bleeding from her throat, because a man punched through two locked doors to reach her, tells you everything about the nature of this crime.
Fled to the border, caught by authorities
After the stabbing, Pasqual did not stay to face what he had done. The District Attorney's Office said he fled California and was later arrested at the United States, Mexico border. The fact that he ran south, toward the border, only underscores the calculation behind the violence. This was not a man overcome by a momentary lapse. He attacked, and then he tried to disappear.
The case draws a sharp contrast with other high-profile figures who have faced serious criminal charges in recent months. Prosecutors have alleged child pornography was found on singer D4vd's phone as a separate murder trial looms, another reminder that fame offers no shield from the justice system when the evidence is damning.
Pasqual's sentencing to more than three decades in prison at least delivers a measure of accountability. The conviction covered attempted murder, forcible rape, first-degree residential burglary, and multiple domestic violence counts. That is a serious stack of charges, and the sentence reflects it.
Accountability, and the question of what came before
The open questions in this case are worth noting. The exact length of the sentence beyond "more than three decades" has not been specified in available reporting. Neither has the court that handled the case, the docket number, nor any statement from Pasqual or his defense attorney at sentencing. Whether Pasqual entered a plea or mounted a defense strategy remains unreported.
What is clear is that Shehorn tried to use the legal system to protect herself before the attack. She filed a restraining order. She accused Pasqual of domestic violence. Days later, he broke into her home anyway.
That pattern, a victim seeking protection, the system granting paper, and the abuser ignoring it, is one that repeats across domestic violence cases nationwide. Restraining orders matter. But they are only as strong as the enforcement behind them.
The entertainment industry has seen a string of high-profile criminal cases in recent years. Sean "Diddy" Combs has taken his own conviction fight to an appeals court, challenging his sentencing as unconstitutional, a very different posture from a defendant who fled to the border.
Shehorn's willingness to testify, scarred and in public, gave the jury what it needed. Her testimony was direct. Her injuries were visible. The evidence spoke for itself.
In other corners of the public-figure accountability landscape, outcomes have been far less satisfying. Baseball player Wander Franco was found guilty of sexually abusing a minor but walked free after a Dominican judge granted a pardon, a result that makes the Pasqual sentence look like a model of justice by comparison.
And the disparities do not end there. Disgraced megachurch pastor Robert Morris walked free after just six months for sexually abusing a child. Six months versus three decades. The gap between those outcomes should trouble anyone who believes the justice system ought to deliver consistent consequences for violent crime.
The sentence Shehorn earned
Pasqual's case is not complicated. A man broke into his ex-girlfriend's home after she sought legal protection from him. He stabbed her more than 20 times. She nearly died on her bathroom floor. He ran for the border. A jury convicted him on every major charge. A judge sentenced him to more than thirty years.
The system worked here, eventually. But it worked because Allie Shehorn survived 14 hours of surgery, spent days in intensive care, and then walked into a courtroom with scars on her neck to face the man who put them there.
That is not the system protecting a victim. That is a victim dragging the system across the finish line.






