Catholics Play a Decisive Role In Trump's Presidential Win
Donald Trump won the 2024 Presidential Election with the significant backing of Catholic voters who favored his conservative policies over Democratic nominee Kamala Harris.
Catholic voters have been instrumental in re-electing President Trump, giving him a substantial edge due to opposition to Harris's policies on religion and abortion, WorldNetDaily reported.
Trump’s victory was significantly paved by the Catholic electorate, an essential demographic that traditionally swings between Republican and Democratic candidates. In the 2024 election cycle, early exit polls reported by *The Washington Post* indicated that Trump led Harris by 18 points among Catholic voters. This shift followed four years after many in the Catholic community voted for Joe Biden, a Democrat who shared their faith.
Biden’s Catholic background played a crucial role in attracting Catholic votes in 2020. However, in this election cycle, neither Harris nor her running mate, Tim Walz, could connect with Catholic voters as effectively. In contrast, Trump’s choice of J.D. Vance, a fellow Catholic, as his running mate boosted his appeal within this critical voter segment.
Catholics Rally Behind Trump Over Religious Values
Ralph Reed, a prominent political commentator and strategist, stated that the Democrats suffer from a "religion problem" that jeopardizes their electoral chances. This issue has repeatedly surfaced in post-election analyses and continues to be a significant challenge for the Democratic Party, particularly about its policies on abortion and religious freedoms.
The perceived anti-Catholic sentiment and the broad support for abortion policies under the Harris campaign exacerbated their struggle with religious voters. Harris's stance and rhetoric during the campaign season drew criticism from conservative religious groups and leaders, who accused her of maintaining a platform that conflicted with religious and pro-life values deeply entrenched within segments of the Catholic community.
Furthermore, in an election where Protestant and other Christian voters also predominantly supported Trump, the overall religious vote shifted dramatically in his favor. Trump won the Protestant and other Christian vote by a margin of 63 to 36, further cementing his support base among religious communities in the United States.
Harris Struggles with Perception of Catholic Issues
Biden's previous success with Catholic voters was attributed to his more visible faith practices and his respectful engagement with Catholic leaders, according to Reed. This personal connection with the faith community was lacking in Harris's campaign approach, which was evident when she chose not to attend the Al Smith charity dinner - an event significant for engaging influential Catholic voters and one traditionally attended by major party candidates.
The absence at the Al Smith dinner was seen by many as a missed opportunity for Harris to mend fences with Catholic voters. Brian Burch, president of CatholicVote, described the decision as "insulting" and reflective of her broader disregard for the Catholic community, resonating with a narrative pushed heavily during the campaign period.
Adding to the contentious atmosphere were accusations from Harris's camp targeting religious freedoms. Policies proposed by the Biden administration on health services, including provisions for transgender surgeries opposed by many religious groups, were seen as further moves away from religious sensibilities. These policies were met with stiff opposition from Catholic and other religious voters who felt their beliefs were under siege.
Election Results Driven by Faith-Based Voting
An FBI memo from February 2023 which described traditionalist Catholics as "radical" before being retracted, also played into the narrative of religious hostility perceived from the Democratic side. This memo was frequently used as an example of how the Democrats view religious groups, contributing to the distrust among religious voters towards the Democratic ticket.
As the final results showed a clear preference for Trump among religious voters, the significance of the Catholic vote could not be overstated. "These numbers are shocking, and could prove to be the largest margin among Catholics in a presidential race in decades," said Burch, highlighting the pivotal role this demographic played in the 2024 election.
Ashley McGuire, a commentator on religious issues, also criticized Harris for running what she described as an "anti-Catholic campaign." She pointed to various statements and policy endorsements by Harris that alienated Catholic voters, ultimately culminating in a significant electoral backlash.
Trump's Triumph Attributed to Religious Voters' Support
In the aftermath, Trump's mandate from religious voters is clear, and his victory has motivated calls for policies that reject anti-Catholic extremism and restore safeguards around America's First Freedom, religious liberty. The 2024 election serves as a potent reminder of the influential role that faith and religious values continue to play in American politics, particularly at the ballot box.