Obama Center subcontractor brings $40M lawsuit for alleged discrimination
Former President Barack Obama is facing a host of new headaches related to his presidential library as rumors about his marital status also continue to swirl.
In a lawsuit against New York-based Thornton Tomasetti, Chicago subcontractor II in One alleges racial discrimination and undue financial hardships caused by unexpectedly strict construction requirements, seeking $40 million in damages, as the New York Post reports.
Initiation of Work and Emerging Disputes
II in One, a provider of concrete and rebar services, began their contribution to the high-profile project back in 2021.
Owner Robert McGee took legal action claiming that Thornton Tomasetti, tasked with overseeing the structural engineering, imposed changes that wouldn’t typically be expected, such as alterations to rebar spacing and tolerance levels, straying from the norms set by the American Concrete Institute.
These modifications necessitated additional inspections and led to substantial financial overruns. McGee argues that these demands were not only excessive but rooted in discriminatory practices that targeted his company because it is Black owned.
Thornton Tomasetti has countered these accusations in memos describing the modifications as necessary due to the subcontractor's alleged deficiencies in meeting project standards.
The company asserts that the financial and project delays were the result of shortcomings from II on One's side, not from any unfair treatment by the engineering firm.
Allegations of Discrimination Emerge
McGee’s legal battle highlights a greater narrative of alleged racial discrimination. He claims that his firm suffered accusations of being underqualified -- a critique not leveled at non-minority contractors involved in the project. This, he suggests, points to discriminatory practices that have jeopardized the survival of his business.
In defense, Thornton Tomasetti provided evidence of poor workmanship by II in One, including photographs of cracked concrete slabs and improperly installed rebar, which they claim justifies their stricter oversight.
The company’s internal documents allude to extensive efforts to support II in One, subtly criticizing the subcontractor's qualifications and arguing that other, more competent firms would not have required such interventions.
Context of the Obama Presidential Center Construction
Located near Jackson Park, the Obama Presidential Center, apart from its political and cultural significance, aims to host a museum, a library, and diverse community facilities under the stewardship of the nonprofit Obama Foundation.
The center’s ground-breaking was celebrated with the presence of Barack and Michelle Obama on Sept. 28, 2021.
Despite initial plans set for 2018, various challenges delayed the start of construction until 2021. The anticipated completion of the center is now set for 2026.
These delays were further complicated by lawsuits and public concern over potential increases in housing costs and environmental impacts.
During the 2021 ground-breaking speech, former President Obama emphasized the center's potential to uplift Chicago's South Side by introducing new green spaces and wildlife habitats, noting the long-term benefits the project was expected to bring to the community.
Broad Impact and Community Reactions
As the lawsuit progresses, it brings to light critical issues of equity and fairness in major construction projects. Allegations of racial discrimination call for a closer look into the practices of major firms involved in significant urban developments, particularly when they impact minority-owned businesses.
The case of II in One vs. Thornton Tomasetti not only questions the fairness and integrity of construction practices but also raises significant concerns about the real cost of such conflicts on the social fabric of the community poised to benefit from such developmental projects.
The outcome of this lawsuit could set important precedents for how subcontractors are treated in the industry, particularly in projects with significant social and cultural implications, ensuring that future endeavors foster inclusivity and fairness across all levels of participation.